In the world of MMA, there are two names that have emerged from Dagestan, whose names quicken heartbeats around the globe: Islam Makhachev and Khabib Nurmagomedov. Both have a relationship akin to "master and disciple" in martial arts, but we will attempt to compare them objectively. Who is stronger? The question is difficult, but it is worth contemplating.
Arguments in favor of Islam Makhachev
First of all, Islam Makhachev's readiness to move up to the 77 kg weight category is noteworthy. Although he has not yet officially fought in the welterweight division, this represents a high-level risk and readiness for new challenges. Khabib, on the other hand, spent his entire career around 70 kg.
Moreover, Makhachev has been leading the "Pound-for-Pound" rankings for 19 months. This demonstrates his superiority and consistent dominance. Khabib, after retiring, was only able to lead this ranking for 6 months.
Additionally, Islam has achieved 15 consecutive victories, coming close to Anderson Silva's record of 16. A victory in his next fight could not only give him a record but also a championship in the second weight category.
Arguments in favor of Khabib Nurmagomedov
Islam may have more statistical advantages, but Khabib's impact and psychology in the octagon are different. When he stepped into the ring, opponents knew he was not a "thinking fighter" but a grappler who "could not escape losing." His skills had reached an unmatchable level.
Furthermore, Khabib's victorious performance against Conor McGregor elevated his image in sports to legendary status. Islam does not have opponents of that caliber: Oliveira and Volkanovski are strong but not "game-changers."
Another point: many acknowledge Khabib's contribution to Makhachev's success. This is not just a personal connection but also highlights Khabib's role as a mentor.
The conclusion is in your hands
Undoubtedly, both are unparalleled stars of their time. Islam is technically modern, while Khabib has a spiritual and psychological impact. Determining which of these two aspects is superior is challenging. However, it is certain that each of them is writing distinct pages in the history of MMA.
Who is preferable? To answer this question, one must consider statistics, style, impact, and the passion of the fans. We leave the opinion to you. One thing is clear: Makhachev and Khabib are not just Dagestanis but a source of pride for the entire world.
